Kalshi vs Polymarket: why the same market has two prices — October 2026

On 19 October 2026 the median gap between Kalshi and Polymarket on the same market was 0.5 cents, and 1 pair in 10 differed by 2 cents or more. The gaps exist because each venue has its own order book, its own depth and its own fees. Two markets that look the same can also settle differently, so a gap is not free money.

By Alexander Korzh · Published · Updated

Two venues, one question, two prices

Kalshi and Polymarket often list the same question: who wins a game, which party wins a race, whether a rate is cut. DOXA matches those markets across venues and shows them side by side on a compare page. Very often the two Yes prices are not equal.

This note explains why, using the numbers from our October 2026 price-gap study.

How big the gaps are

We took the 120 Kalshi and Polymarket pairs that DOXA trusts for its merged order book, as they stood at about 22:00 UTC on 19 October 2026. Each side had to be open, priced in the previous 24 hours, priced between 2 and 98 cents, and hold at least $1,000 of liquidity.

Gap between the two Yes pricesPairsShare
1 cent or more5041.7%
2 cents or more1210.0%
5 cents or more21.7%
10 cents or more10.8%

The median gap was 0.5 cents and the mean 1.05 cents. Kalshi was the higher price in 65 pairs, Polymarket in 36, and 19 pairs were level. Most gaps are small, and a few are large.

Why the prices differ

Separate order books

A price on either venue is set only by the orders on that venue. A buyer on Kalshi does not trade against a seller on Polymarket. The two books hold different traders, react to news at different speeds and are not linked, so nothing forces them to agree at any moment.

Depth

A thin book moves further on each order. In October the two widest gaps, 12.5 and 10 cents, were both college football lines with between $1,100 and $1,600 of liquidity on the thinner side. The widest gaps were where the books were thinnest.

Depth also limits what a gap is worth. The price you see is for the first few contracts. A larger order walks down the book and pays more on average, and on a thin book the gap can close after a few dollars.

Fees

Kalshi charges a taker fee of 7% × contracts × P × (1 − P), where P is the price in dollars, rounded up to the next cent. On some markets the rate is lower. At 50 cents that is about 1.75 cents per contract, more than three times the median gap.

Polymarket charges a taker fee on many markets too. It is taken out of the fill itself, and the rate depends on the market. On both venues the fee is largest for prices near 50 cents and smallest near 0 or 100.

In October, 58% of pairs differed by less than 1 cent. That is less than Kalshi's fee alone on a contract priced between about 18 and 82 cents.

The bid–ask spread

The prices in the study are each venue's latest Yes price. To buy, you pay the ask, which sits above that price. To sell, you get the bid, which sits below it. The spread on each side adds to the cost of acting on a gap.

Why resolution wording matters

Two markets can carry the same title and still settle differently. Each venue writes its own rules, and the details can differ:

  • the exact deadline, and the time zone it is in;
  • which source decides the result;
  • what happens if a game is postponed, a candidate withdraws or a figure is revised;
  • whether overtime, a recount or a late announcement counts.

The venues also decide in different ways. Kalshi is a regulated exchange in the US and settles each market under its own published contract rules. Polymarket proposes an outcome through the UMA oracle, and that outcome can be disputed before it is final.

If the rules differ, the two markets are not the same bet, and part of the price gap may simply reflect that difference. Every DOXA compare page has a Resolution rules section with each venue's rules side by side. Read it before you rely on a gap.

Is a price gap an arbitrage?

Usually not. "Kalshi Polymarket arbitrage" means buying Yes on one venue and No on the other so that one side pays whatever happens. For that to make money, the gap has to be larger than both venues' fees and spreads together, the size has to be there on both books at once, and both markets have to settle the same way. In October, 9 pairs in 10 were within 2 cents of each other, which is about what the fees alone cost on a contract near 50 cents.

DOXA does not place two-leg arbitrage trades: it never buys Yes on one venue and No on the other to lock in a gap. What DOXA does is show you the best price for an outcome across venues, so that when you buy, you buy where it is cheapest.

What this note does not show

  • One moment. The numbers are one snapshot from 19 October 2026, not an average over the month.
  • Latest prices, not executable ones. They do not include fees, spreads or depth.
  • Only pairs DOXA trusts. Markets we have not matched, or have quarantined after an automated check, are left out.

To see the prices for one event side by side, with each venue's rules, open its compare page, for example Copa Libertadores winner.

A price on DOXA is the market-implied probability of an outcome on the venue that lists it. It is what traders are paying, not a forecast made by DOXA, and it is not investment advice. How DOXA shows prices · Terms of Use